Florida AG Declares State Gun Restriction Unconstitutional, Drops Defense
A state attorney general withdrawing a legal defense forces courts to find alternative defenders of a statute, a process that can accelerate or complicate a law's constitutional fate.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier announced on November 17, 2026, that his office has concluded a Florida gun restriction violates the Second Amendment and will no longer defend the law in court, according to a statement reported by the Daily Caller.
The specific statute at issue was not fully detailed in the available source material. The precise statutory citation, the nature of the firearm restriction, and the litigation docket number are not confirmed in the reporting reviewed by The Congressional Times. Those details would appear in a formal court filing or the attorney general's official press release, neither of which had been published to a public docket as of this writing.
When a state attorney general declines to defend a law, the legislature or another state official may step in as an intervenor to continue the defense. Under established federal procedural rules, courts can allow third-party intervention when the named defendant withdraws or refuses to litigate. Florida's legislature would be the most likely body to seek intervention, though no such filing was confirmed in the available record as of November 17, 2026.
The announcement is the attorney general's second such declaration on gun statutes, according to the Daily Caller report, which noted the office stated this is "another" law it has concluded conflicts with the Second Amendment. The earlier instance and its outcome are not identified in available source material. The Florida AG's official press office would hold records of prior non-defense determinations.
The legal backdrop for such decisions has shifted significantly since the United States Supreme Court issued its ruling in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen in 2022. Under Bruen, courts are required to assess firearm regulations against the historical tradition of firearms regulation in the United States at the time of the founding, rather than applying a means-ends balancing test. Lower courts have since reached divergent conclusions applying that standard to a range of state and federal restrictions.
Florida has been a frequent venue for Second Amendment litigation. The state passed a measure in 2018 raising the minimum purchase age for long guns to 21 following the Parkland school shooting. That law was challenged in federal court, and the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals upheld it in a 2023 decision. Whether the law now disavowed by the AG's office is related to that or another restriction is not confirmed in the available source material.
At the federal level, the Department of Justice has also faced questions about which regulations to defend in court following changes in administration. The current administration's posture on federal gun regulations and coordination with state attorneys general on Second Amendment matters is not addressed in the available record for this specific announcement.
The practical effect on Florida residents and gun owners depends on the specific restriction at issue, which remains unconfirmed. If the law remains on the books without an active legal defense, it may continue to be enforced by local authorities until a court issues an injunction or final ruling. Enforcement responsibility and any active injunctions are unknown from the available source material.
The Florida legislature, which passed the original restriction, has not issued a public response as of November 17, 2026, based on available records. Legislative leadership's position on intervention would appear in committee records or floor statements in the Florida House and Senate journals.
What remains unknown: the exact statutory citation for the law the AG declined to defend, the case name and docket number, any court response to the withdrawal, and whether the Florida legislature intends to intervene. The Florida AG's official press releases, the relevant federal or state court docket, and Florida legislative records would answer each of those questions.