IRS Cuts Conservation Easement Valuations by Average 97%, Study Finds
A pattern of large valuation reductions across 115 examined cases raises questions about whether IRS methodology is consistently applied or adequately transparent to landowners.
A study by Infinity Advisory Services examined 115 conservation easement cases and found that the Internal Revenue Service reduced claimed conservation easement deductions by an average of roughly 97 percent, according to a Fox News report published November 17, 2026. The finding puts a specific number on a dispute that has drawn congressional attention and at least one whistleblower account.
Conservation easements are legal agreements in which a landowner voluntarily restricts development rights on a parcel of land, typically in exchange for a federal tax deduction equal to the diminished value of the property. The IRS is authorized under the Internal Revenue Code, specifically Section 170(h), to allow such deductions when the easement meets defined conservation purposes.
The Infinity Advisory Services study, cited in the Fox News report, found that the IRS did not simply deny deductions outright in the 115 cases reviewed but instead accepted that easements existed while dramatically reducing the valuation basis used to calculate the deduction. The average reduction of approximately 97 percent means that for every $1 million a landowner claimed, the IRS on average allowed roughly $30,000 in deductible value.
The report also referenced a whistleblower who alleged that IRS examiners applied valuation methodologies inconsistently and without adequate notice to taxpayers about the standards that would be used to evaluate their appraisals. The identity of the whistleblower and the specific procedural vehicle used to bring that account forward, whether through the IRS Whistleblower Office, a congressional referral, or a court filing, was not specified in the available source material. A formal whistleblower submission to the IRS Whistleblower Office would be on file with that agency under 26 U.S.C. Section 7623, but those records are not public by default.
Conservation easements have been a point of contention between the IRS and taxpayers for more than a decade. The agency designated syndicated conservation easement transactions as listed transactions, a category reserved for arrangements considered abusive tax shelters, in Notice 2017-10, published in January 2017 during the Obama administration. That designation required disclosure of such transactions on federal tax returns and subjected participants to enhanced scrutiny.
Congress addressed the issue legislatively in the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022, signed into law December 29, 2022 (Public Law 117-328), which included provisions limiting deductions for syndicated easement transactions to 2.5 times a partner's contributed basis. That statutory cap applied specifically to partnerships and did not cover all individual conservation easement claims.
The 115 cases examined in the Infinity Advisory Services study represent a subset of total IRS conservation easement audits. The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration reported in a 2023 audit (Report 2023-10-016) that the IRS had thousands of open conservation easement cases in its inventory, with an aggregate claimed deduction value in the billions of dollars. The share of those total cases represented by the 115-case sample studied by Infinity Advisory Services is therefore small, and whether the 97 percent average reduction holds across the broader IRS inventory is unknown.
Landowners who receive IRS notices reducing easement valuations may challenge the determinations in United States Tax Court. Tax Court decisions in conservation easement cases are public records. Several rulings in 2024 and 2025 upheld IRS reductions, while a smaller number found in favor of taxpayers on procedural or valuation grounds. A comprehensive count of outcomes across all such Tax Court cases is not available in the current source material.
The IRS has not publicly responded to the specific findings of the Infinity Advisory Services study as of the publication date of the Fox News report. An IRS response, if issued, would likely appear as a formal statement on IRS.gov or in a Tax Court brief if litigation is pending.
Conservational groups and farm bureaus have separately argued that aggressive IRS scrutiny of legitimate easements discourages voluntary land conservation, while IRS officials have maintained that the program has been exploited by promoters who inflate appraisals. Neither claim in that debate is independently adjudicated by this publication.
What remains unknown is the full methodology used by Infinity Advisory Services to select its 115-case sample, whether those cases were drawn from syndicated transactions, individual landowner filings, or both, and whether a whistleblower complaint has been formally filed with either the IRS Whistleblower Office or a congressional oversight committee. Those details, if they exist as public records, would be found in IRS Whistleblower Office acknowledgment letters, congressional correspondence logs, or Tax Court dockets.